Early at Anvil, I hired capable generalists who could do the technical work and manage the client relationship. That made sense when we were smaller. As the agency grew, I learned the limits of assuming one person should be equally good at analysis, creative problem-solving and difficult client conversations.
I've seen brilliant specialists become miserable account leads. I've also seen excellent client-facing people struggle when asked to be the deepest technical expert in the room. Neither is a character flaw. It's usually a role-design problem.
Role-ownership map
Try this with your own figures or decisions. It runs in your browser; nothing is submitted.
For reflection and planning only. Illustrative scores and estimates are not forecasts, legal, accounting or investment advice.Six months later, everyone is frustrated. The specialist is drained by meetings, the client wants clearer communication and the founder wonders why a promising hire stopped looking so promising.
Maybe the hire wasn't the problem. Maybe the job was.
In Anvil's earlier years, I hired bright generalists who could both manage client relationships and do the work. As the agency evolved, I realized that the overlap between those skills was smaller than I had assumed. Some great account managers struggled with technical execution. Some excellent practitioners were miserable having to manage every aspect of a client relationship.
Separating account management from subject-matter expertise was an important step for us. It helped people lean into their strengths rather than forcing every talented person into the same career path.
Stop promoting your best doer into your biggest mismatch
A talented analyst does not automatically want to manage people. An inspired designer may not enjoy negotiating scope. A search strategist can produce excellent thinking while finding weekly status calls exhausting.
None of that means these people lack ambition or leadership potential. It means there are different forms of expertise.
The agency's job is to create paths for people to become more valuable without requiring everyone to become an account director. Otherwise, you effectively punish mastery: the reward for getting exceptionally good at a craft is being asked to do less of it.
I've seen enough agencies to know there isn't one perfect organizational chart. In a small company, people must wear multiple hats. The mistake is refusing to revisit those hats when the business becomes big enough to specialize.
Define what each role is actually accountable for
When I look at how an agency organizes its people, I would separate three questions:
Who owns the client relationship? Someone needs to understand the buyer's goals, keep promises realistic, communicate changes and spot risks to the relationship. That requires judgment and context across services.
Who owns the specialist judgment? Technical professionals need the authority to recommend approaches, challenge weak assumptions and improve their craft. They shouldn't have to negotiate every commercial detail to make a sound technical call.
Who owns the commercial trade-off? Scope changes, pricing, staffing and exceptions need clear authority. If nobody owns these decisions, they end up on the founder's desk at 8:30 on a Friday evening.
A single person can hold more than one role if they have the appetite and capability. But don't assume that because someone is good at one of them, they're good at all three.
The impressive resume that didn't fit
I've also shared another hiring mistake from Anvil: bringing in experienced talent from prominent technology companies, including Google and Yahoo, and discovering that some people weren't the right cultural fit.
Those credentials were legitimate. They simply didn't guarantee success in our environment. In fact, some less experienced hires whom we developed internally became stronger fits and grew into industry leaders.
The broader lesson isn't to avoid big-brand employers or hire inexperienced people by default. It's to stop allowing a logo to substitute for evidence about how someone will work in your organization.
Agency life can require rapid context switching, explaining uncertainty to clients, collaborating across disciplines and succeeding without the resources available at a massive technology firm. A brilliant person can fail in the wrong context. An overlooked person can flourish with the right support.
Four interview questions that reveal more than a job title
For a technical hire, I would ask:
- Tell me about a time you had to explain a recommendation to someone who disagreed. What did you change about your explanation?
- Which part of client communication energizes you, and which part drains you?
- When another specialist challenges your work, what helps you decide whether to change course?
- Describe an environment where you've done your best work. What made it work?
For account leadership, I'd change the emphasis: How do they surface unwelcome news? How do they handle a scope problem without throwing the delivery team under the bus? How do they learn enough about a specialist's work to represent it accurately?
Those questions won't eliminate hiring mistakes. They may, however, uncover the difference between knowing the discipline and wanting the role.
Your org chart should help clients, not just employees
Separating responsibilities is not a license to build silos. A client should never feel that the person who understands their goals and the person doing the work have stopped talking.
Good account leadership creates room for the specialist to do better work and gives the client confidence that someone sees the whole picture. Good specialists give account leaders the facts and options needed to communicate honestly. When that relationship works, clients get better counsel and employees spend more of their time doing work they are suited to do.
The key is deliberate collaboration, not vague expectations that "everyone owns the client."
A promotion isn't always a promotion
Before giving your best specialist an account-management job, ask whether you're recognizing their strengths or replacing them with a role the business urgently needs filled.
Sometimes the right move is to develop that person as a practice leader, mentor or senior technical authority. Sometimes it's to support them into client leadership because they genuinely want to grow in that direction. The employee should help answer the question.
I spent a long time learning that a successful agency isn't staffed by interchangeable high achievers. It's staffed by different people who understand how their contributions fit together.
If your next hire or promotion will reshape the way your agency operates, agency founder advisory can help you examine the roles and trade-offs before you make a permanent decision.
What I'd do next
A better org chart doesn't automatically create a better agency. The handoffs between people are where accountability can disappear. Give the client one clear relationship owner, specialists authority over the craft and a named decision maker for scope and commercial exceptions.
If the same person holds all three responsibilities in a small agency, make it a conscious decision and monitor the load. The goal isn't to create job titles. It's to put people where their strengths improve client outcomes without asking them to become someone else.