I walked away from an acquisition conversation in 2019. That decision wasn't nearly as dramatic as a signed deal, but it helped clarify what I was unwilling to compromise on. When Anvil ultimately merged with Deksia in 2022, the price mattered. So did the people who would be carrying the business forward.
The financial terms are what everyone wants to discuss at dinner. The harder questions arrive on Monday: Who is responsible for the team? Which promises survive the integration? And what exactly is the founder signing up to do next?
Partner-fit scorecard
Try this with your own figures or decisions. It runs in your browser; nothing is submitted.
For reflection and planning only. Illustrative scores and estimates are not forecasts, legal, accounting or investment advice.Those questions matter. They just aren't the only questions.
I started Anvil in October 2000. By 2005, I'd already entertained an acquisition conversation. Over the years, other opportunities surfaced. In 2019, I backed out of a potential deal because the fit wasn't right. I had learned enough to know that an attractive transaction could still create a future I didn't want for my team or myself.
In late 2020, I connected with Aaron VanderGalien, another Entrepreneurs' Organization member who led Deksia. We got along, but neither company was quite ready. The relationship continued, the timing changed and our agencies merged on March 1, 2022.
I wrote about that experience for Inc. shortly afterward. Looking back, what stands out isn't a clever negotiating tactic. It's that we treated the relationship, the team and the operating future as serious parts of the deal.
The number can't answer what happens on Monday
A founder can sell a business and still wake up the following week with responsibility for employees, clients, reputation and a new boss or partner. Depending on the structure, the company may not really disappear at all; it may become part of something bigger.
That's why I would start by asking what the owner is actually trying to achieve. Liquidity? A stronger client offering? Less operational responsibility? A path for employees? More time for other interests? There is no right answer, but there are deals that suit one objective and undermine another.
If you haven't identified your objective, you're at risk of letting a buyer's proposal define it for you.
My first non-financial test: would I trust these people with my team?
A marketing agency sells expertise, relationships and judgment. The people are a large part of the product. A partner that looks wonderful on paper can still be wrong for the work and the culture.
With Deksia, I had the chance to attend a quarterly all-hands meeting in Chicago and spend time with the team. Their people later came to Portland to meet Anvil's staff as well. Those interactions mattered. I wasn't just evaluating a presentation about culture; I was getting a sense of how people worked together.
There's a practical lesson for owners considering a merger: spend time with the humans who will shape the next chapter. Speak to people beyond the deal team. Ask how decisions are made, how disagreements are resolved and what happens when the integration becomes inconvenient.
A glossy deck can make almost any culture look compatible. The actual meetings are more revealing.
My second test: are our strengths genuinely complementary?
Agency owners often fall in love with the idea of "scale" as though bigger were automatically better. A combination should create something that clients and employees couldn't already access as easily through the separate businesses.
We saw potential in complementary services, locations and capabilities. That is a more concrete proposition than "two agencies are better than one." But even a compelling strategic fit doesn't eliminate execution risk. You still need to decide who will own which clients, which processes survive and how internal teams will work together.
The merger announcement is a moment. Integration is the work.
My third test: can we be candid about the money early?
One practical lesson I shared in my Inc. article was to establish my target number early. It saved us from spending months on a deal that couldn't work financially. It didn't mean skipping proper valuation, legal diligence or tax advice. It meant admitting that no amount of goodwill could rescue a proposal with fundamentally incompatible expectations.
Agency founders often postpone difficult conversations because they like the people in the room. That's understandable. It's also expensive when months of management attention disappear into a transaction that had no realistic starting point.
Get to the real constraints sooner. Then let specialists handle the transaction detail rather than pretending to be your own lawyer, banker and tax adviser.
My fourth test: will the business become more resilient—or simply more complicated?
One reason Deksia interested me was its use of the Entrepreneurial Operating System. I valued the structure and accountability it brought to an expanding organization. That didn't remove every risk, but it offered something tangible beyond the promise of extra revenue.
Ask a potential partner to show you how the combined agency will operate. Who decides on staffing? How do services get priced? Who owns a client conflict? How will profitability be measured across teams? What happens when two leaders have different views about the same account?
If everyone says "we'll work that out after closing," I'd get nervous.
My fifth test: do I want the personal role being offered?
An exit changes the founder's identity as much as the cap table. For years, I was the person leading Anvil. After the merger, I stepped into a different role. I learned more about being an employee again than I might have expected.
That doesn't make mergers bad. It means the founder should understand the day after the party. Will you still have authority? What responsibilities will stay with you? Where will you need permission? Are you comfortable with the answer?
The role is not a footnote. It's part of what you're agreeing to.
Sometimes the best answer is “not this deal”
I don't regret taking the time to find the right fit. Saying no in 2019 helped clarify what mattered when the next opportunity appeared. Patience wasn't passive; it created room for a better decision.
If you're considering a sale or merger, you need experienced legal, financial and tax advisers. I don't replace them. My contribution is an operator's perspective on the parts of the decision that a spreadsheet can't settle: your people, your client relationships, your role and what kind of life you want after the deal.
Considering a partnership or exit but not certain what you want from it? We can start with those questions in an agency-founder advisory session—before you spend months pursuing the wrong opportunity.
What I'd do next
In my own experience, spending time with the Deksia team in Chicago was more revealing than a pitch deck. It helped me see whether the fit existed beyond a spreadsheet. That does not eliminate transaction risk, but it makes one important part of the decision less abstract.
My advice to a founder considering a sale is to write down a personal deal thesis before reviewing the offer. What must be true for employees, clients, the operating model and your own next chapter? Financial, legal and tax advisers still need to do their work; this is the human test they can't do for you.