I could tell you that a well-written set of values transformed my agency. That would make a much neater story than the one I have actually told in interviews.
In 2013, we rebuilt Anvil's culture around what we called the Credo. The change was significant and so was the disruption. Employees left. Over the years that followed, we worked towards a healthier, more consistent experience for the people doing the work.
I'm not celebrating the disruption. I'm reflecting on what it revealed. Agency founders love a good strategy document. Sometimes the most important cultural document is the set of decisions the founder makes when nobody is applauding.
The values on the wall are not the values at work
Most agencies can assemble a beautiful list: collaboration, creativity, curiosity, accountability, respect. Each is attractive. None answers the question of what happens when a high performer makes colleagues miserable, when a major client treats an employee badly, or when a manager delivers on revenue while driving people away.
Culture is revealed by what gets rewarded, what gets tolerated and who feels safe enough to tell leadership that something is wrong. One uncomfortable decision usually teaches employees more about their company's principles than a very expensive retreat.
At Anvil, I came to believe the team should be the first priority and clients the second. I have explained that publicly, including why we ended relationships with major clients whose behavior crossed a line. This was never about caring less about client results. It was a recognition that the employees delivering those results deserve an environment in which they can do their best work.
Don't turn somebody else's painful reset into a recipe
One of the dangers of the turnaround story is that it can make employee departures sound like a clever leadership tactic. They aren't. People have livelihoods, histories, commitments and relationships. Turnover disrupts clients, institutional knowledge, recruiting and morale. A hard decision may occasionally be necessary, but “clean house” is a terrible substitute for diagnosis.
Before announcing a sweeping cultural change, I would ask a founder to identify the specific failures in the system. Are expectations clear? Are managers being coached and held accountable? Do bonuses reward behavior that conflicts with stated values? Is an overwhelmed team carrying the consequences of unrealistic sales promises? Do employees believe there is a safe way to raise a problem?
Sometimes the honest answer is that a leader needs to change before anyone else does. That's not a slogan. It means listening to information you may not want and changing a decision-making habit that has been financially or emotionally convenient.
Why an open-door policy can still leave the founder in the dark
In a published interview, I discussed discovering how important information had not reached me through layers of management. It was a lesson in the difference between being approachable and actually hearing what the company is experiencing.
A founder can be genuinely friendly and still be the last person to know that people are struggling. Staff pay attention to what happens after someone raises a concern. If speaking honestly leads to no action—or worse, a career penalty—an “open door” won't do much.
At Anvil, the tools included conversations, surveys and retreats. None of those is magical. Their usefulness depends on whether people can participate candidly and whether leaders respond in ways employees can see.
A three-part culture diagnosis for an agency owner
First, find the actual experience. Ask people in different roles to describe what happens when delivery is late, a client is unhappy or an employee challenges a decision. Compare answers. If leadership and frontline employees describe two different companies, you have found work to do.
Second, identify the contradictory incentives. If the bonus is based solely on new revenue, don't be shocked when someone sells commitments the team cannot realistically fulfil. If account leaders are rewarded only for retention, they may tolerate unacceptable client behavior. Align measurement with the principles you say matter.
Third, follow through with visible but proportionate action. Clarify standards, coach capable people, repair a broken process, protect those reporting concerns and communicate why changes were made. Difficult personnel decisions should be fact-based and respectful, with appropriate HR and legal advice, not performative attempts to make an example of someone.
Six questions worth asking before the next retreat
- Which behavior do we routinely reward that contradicts a value we publicly claim?
- Where do strong employees regularly compensate for weak management or unclear scopes?
- Can someone challenge a senior leader without fearing the consequences?
- What would we do if the largest client mistreated one of our people tomorrow?
- When somebody leaves, do we learn the real reason—or only the polite version?
- Which recent decision proves that our culture matters even when there is a financial cost?
Don't turn those questions into yet another slide deck. Choose one or two gaps, name a responsible leader and review the specific improvement. Culture work is measured in operating behavior, not in the number of values printed on the office wall.
Caring and high standards belong together
Putting employees first is not a promise that performance no longer matters. Unclear standards can be very unfair to conscientious colleagues, who end up carrying the work others have not done. A healthier culture asks leaders to be clearer about expectations, faster with useful feedback and more consistent about consequences.
It also asks leaders to resist a temptation I understand: assuming success in one corner of the business is proof that everything else is fine. Margins, client satisfaction, turnover, engagement and the stories people tell when leadership isn't there all belong in the picture.
The real test is the next inconvenient decision
Over time, Anvil developed a healthier culture. I have described the process publicly, including how long it took. I don't claim that our path is a universal blueprint or that it was elegant. It was an experience that changed how I think about responsibility for the people who deliver an agency's work.
If you're facing a problem that has grown beyond one unhappy employee or one difficult account, connect this reflection with the decision behind firing a client and the guide to giving leaders meaningful decision rights. It's often the decisions around culture, not the manifesto itself, that need the founder's attention.
What happened in 2013—and why context matters
Kent's published Authority Magazine interview describes a 2013 Credo reset and substantial turnover, followed by a multi-year change in how Anvil prioritised employees. In a separate public interview, he described the immediate cost in human terms, including seven colleagues leaving in the first week. He explicitly cautioned against treating large-scale turnover as the route to profitability.
There is an important distinction between documenting what happened in one business and recommending that another founder repeat the experience. You cannot solve a complex people problem by writing a stricter manifesto and hoping the right employees remain. Diagnosis, expectations, support, proportionality and lawful employment practice all matter.
Test one value against three decisions
Choose a value such as care, curiosity or accountability. Find the most recent hiring decision, difficult client interaction and internal escalation where it should have mattered. Ask three people affected what the organisation actually did. Then write down one behaviour the management team will change and a date to check whether it stuck.
A cultural reset needs a feedback loop, not just a launch day
Anonymous surveys can reveal patterns, one-to-ones can explain the context, and retrospectives can show whether decisions worked. But employee trust depends on honest follow-through. Avoid asking people for sensitive feedback you cannot safely receive or act on, and avoid identifying individuals from small survey groups. For the linked operational questions, examine where authority really sits and how client behavior tests the company's standards.
The values meeting is not the hard part.
Bring the uncomfortable people or leadership decision behind the culture statement. We can examine the trade-offs without motivational slogans.
EXPLORE FOUNDER ADVISORY ↗